How bad can a live-service MMO's launch disaster get? NetEase's martial arts MMO 'She Diao' just set a new bar: a brand-new game mode shipped with game-breaking duplication bugs, endgame gear got farmed infinitely, the entire server economy crashed overnight — and the studio's idea of compensation was 200 bound ingots per player. Yes, really.
【The Setup: A 'One World, One Server' Promise Gone Wrong】
She Diao's big selling point was its 'world server' system — all servers share one unified trading house and economy. Sounds great in theory. That is, until May 13, when a new gameplay mode launched exclusively for the first 5 servers (called 'small worlds' that players can't transfer between), while the remaining 100+ servers were told to wait until the next day.
The new mode dropped two of the game's most coveted rewards: 480-grade BiS (Best-in-Slot) equipment and 'Hundred Jade Marrow' — an ultra-rare material trading at roughly 14 million silver per piece, equivalent to about 900 RMB (~$125 USD) through official channels. A full BiS set requires 36 of them. Normally, you'd need to clear the ultimate raid twice a week with abysmal drop rates. The original poster had been grinding for three weeks and was nowhere close to finishing.
But the new mode was riddled with bugs. What should have been a 4-runs-per-week activity became infinitely repeatable. A 'Mysterious Merchant' NPC was spawning after nearly every clear, selling cash shop packages at absurdly discounted prices: 30 RMB gacha pulls with decent odds at Hundred Jade Marrow, and a 6 RMB package giving 300,000 silver (the normal rate was 3 RMB for 50,000 — an 18x discount).
The result? Players on the first 5 servers went absolutely wild. Mountains of 480-grade gear and rare materials flooded the game. Some tradable items ended up on the shared auction house, and the market supply of certain cash shop items exploded from zero to hundreds of listings overnight. The game's economy, shared across ALL servers, took a massive hit from an exploit that only a fraction of players had access to.
One upvoted comment initially downplayed it — 'Duplication bugs happen in tons of MMOs, no game ever died from one' — but was immediately met with a devastating counter-argument that got even more upvotes: 'The problem IS that it was only 5 servers. Because everything is connected — auction house, economy, everything — but only those 5 servers could access the exploit. That's what makes it nuclear.'
【The Response: A Day Late, 200 Ingots Short】
The bug existed from the moment the mode launched on May 13 morning. The official team didn't post an announcement until late that night, and the actual 'compensation plan' didn't arrive until the next day — over 24 hours later. Here's what they came up with:
1. Weekly cap increased to 10 uses. Players who already exceeded this? They'll have future weeks' quota deducted. Items stay.
2. They claimed 480-grade set pieces wouldn't drop, but admitted that BiS accessories DID drop. Their wording essentially translated to: 'They already got extra gear, we took away some future runs, please stop yelling.'
3. The Mysterious Merchant spawn-after-every-clear bug is fixed. Previous drops? 'Just pretend you didn't see them, okay?'
4. The 6 RMB silver package now limited to one purchase per cycle. Previous purchases honored.
5. They denied claims of players farming hundreds of millions of silver, but confirmed 'several million is real.'
6. Promised to reopen the mode within two days.
Compensation: 200 bound ingots and 3 gear tokens per player. That's it.
One top comment nailed it: 'This didn't just hit an artery — it severed it.' Another player laid out why this is essentially unfixable: rollback? Too much time has passed. Track and claw back individual items? Impossible once they've entered the unified auction house. Generous compensation? If you give everyone enough to catch up, nobody has any reason to spend money anymore — they'd all be geared.
【The Real Kicker: No Test Server】
But the detail that truly broke the community was buried in the official email: when asked why there was no test server, the developers admitted they 'can't make a test server — never done it, don't know how.' Translation: the live servers with hundreds of thousands of paying players WERE the test environment, and the first 5 servers' players were the unwitting guinea pigs.
A commenter put it perfectly: 'The insane part is they didn't test this on a test server — they picked 5 live servers to beta test. Those 5 servers got to exploit bugs AND farm BiS gear effortlessly, while everyone else gets nothing. Of course people are furious.'
【Bad Blood: Channel Server Prices at 1/4 of Official】
The poster also revealed this wasn't She Diao's first controversy. Previously, 'channel servers' (third-party distribution platforms) shared all gameplay data with official servers — same dungeons, same raids — but had a SEPARATE auction house where prices were 1/3 to 1/4 of official server prices. That outrage got quietly suppressed. This time, the community isn't letting it go.
The in-game world chat descended into total chaos: 'Nobody is actually playing the game — everyone is talking about the bug.' The original poster closed with a darkly humorous jab: 'If I were the game's producer, I'd already be drafting my resignation letter — just hoping NetEase doesn't come after me for damages. Our ten-billion-yuan-budget game just gave everyone a spectacular fireworks show. Popcorn time.'
As of May 14, the official team has emailed out the 'final' compensation — 200 bound ingots and 3 gear tokens, with a message the community has dissected line by line. The gist: 'Those who benefited from the bugs keep their gains, this is all you're getting, don't be ungrateful.' Players say the fireworks just keep getting bigger.
评论 (0)
暂无评论，来说两句吧！ 🍉