If there's one iron rule in the Chinese gacha/SLG scene, it's this: never mess with strategy game veterans — they have deep wallets, endless free time, and the audacity to show up at your office IRL if you cross them. Bilibili's game division apparently missed that memo. Their upcoming SLG 'Three Kingdoms: Strategy' just locked out a huge number of loyal whales from its second paid beta — players who dropped thousands of RMB during Beta 1 — while handing those coveted slots to brand-new accounts and iOS users. The backlash was instantaneous.
Here's the context: 'Three Kingdoms: Strategy' is Bilibili's big SLG play, positioning itself as a lighter, cheaper alternative to heavyweights like 'Three Kingdoms: Strategic Edition' and 'Erta of the Boundary.' After the first paid beta wrapped, players were hyped for a May Day launch — streamers were dropping hints, the App Store listing seemed ready to go. Then, out of nowhere, the devs announced a surprise second paid beta lasting just half a month. For an SLG where a single season cycle takes roughly 30 days, that's barely enough time to scratch the surface, which already felt rushed.
But the real drama hit when the beta access check page went live that evening. Tons of Android veterans who had spent thousands (some tens of thousands) of RMB during Beta 1 discovered they simply didn't get an invite. Players quickly pieced it together: the vast majority of slots went to new players and iOS users, while loyal paying Android players who had supported the game from day one were left out in the cold.
Naturally, these players were livid. Many felt the move was a cynical play to farm fresh spenders with the beta's cashback rewards while spitting on the veterans who kept the lights on. Negative reviews started flooding in, and the community erupted.
The NGA comment section went full scorched earth. One highly upvoted reply asked, 'Did Bilibili's ops team even think about this?' Another piled on: 'Now I understand why every Bilibili-published game just rides FGO's coattails — pure clown show from a circus operation.' Others were even more brutal: 'Wait, Bilibili's mobile game department hasn't been fully laid off yet?' and 'The mobile game graveyard isn't just a meme, it's a prophecy.'
Some commenters did offer a more analytical take, noting that prioritizing new-player metrics is a known industry tactic — studios want to test acquisition rates and see if ads convert. One user even unearthed a wilder example: a Guangdong-based studio literally renamed a game that had already gone through three betas, threw it on Douyin (Chinese TikTok) ads to test random passerby downloads, and banned all returning testers. When the Douyin numbers came back disappointing, they killed the project outright — leaving players who'd bought battle passes and monthly cards with nothing.
It's also worth noting that the game had been actively poaching large guilds from the declining 'Glory of Three Kingdoms 3,' showing that the studio clearly invested in player acquisition — just with the wrong priorities.
Thankfully, the backlash reached the devs fast. By noon on April 15th, Bilibili issued an emergency backtrack, promising beta access to all returning testers from previous betas. The OP confirmed they could now see their own access granted. But the OP's verdict was cutting: 'My take? Where was this energy before you screwed up?'
All in all, this incident is yet another chapter in Bilibili's long-running saga of tone-deaf game operations. In a genre like SLG where whale loyalty is literally the business model, alienating your paying veterans to chase new-user metrics is a galaxy-brain move that only nets you bad press and broken trust. The damage control came fast, but as one top comment put it: 'Seeing that Bilibili's game division is still this emotionally unintelligent gives me the warm fuzzy feeling of confirmation bias. Some things never change.'
评论 (0)
暂无评论，来说两句吧！ 🍉